🌏 閱讀中文版本
In modern cloud services, IaaS (Infrastructure as a Service), PaaS (Platform as a Service), and SaaS (Software as a Service) are three core service models that provide different levels of automation and management capabilities. This article uses Azure and AWS as examples to explain the definitions, application examples, and use cases of these three services, helping you choose the right cloud service model in practice.
Why Do You Need to Understand IaaS, PaaS, and SaaS?
Technical Decision Considerations:
- Control Level: IaaS offers the most control, SaaS offers the least
- Management Responsibility: From complete self-management (IaaS) to fully managed by service provider (SaaS)
- Cost Structure: Different models have vastly different cost calculations and Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
- Deployment Speed: SaaS is fastest, IaaS requires more setup time
Selection Criteria:
- Need complete infrastructure control → IaaS
- Focus on application development without managing servers → PaaS
- Use ready-made software services → SaaS
1. What Is IaaS? (Infrastructure as a Service)
Definition
IaaS provides virtualized infrastructure resources, including compute, storage, and networking, allowing users to install operating systems and manage applications themselves.
Azure and AWS Examples
| Cloud Platform | Service Name | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Azure | Azure Virtual Machines | Full control over OS and applications |
| AWS | Amazon EC2 | Instance configuration similar to Azure VM |
Use Cases
- Development and Test Environments: Need custom OS or software configurations
- Legacy Application Migration: Move existing on-premises applications to cloud
- High Customization Needs: Need to install specific software or adjust system settings
- Large-Scale Computing: Batch processing jobs requiring massive compute resources
Practical Steps (Azure Virtual Machines)
- Create Virtual Machine
- In Azure Portal, select “Create a resource” → “Virtual machine”
- Choose operating system (Windows Server or Linux distribution)
- Configure Resources
- Select VM size (CPU, RAM, disk)
- Configure network and security rules
- Choose storage type (Standard HDD / Premium SSD)
- Remote Management
- Windows: Connect via RDP (Remote Desktop Protocol)
- Linux: Connect via SSH
Cost Considerations
- Hourly billing (compute resources + storage)
- Self-manage patches, backups, monitoring
- Suitable for long-running stable workloads
Reference: Azure Virtual Machines Official Documentation
2. What Is PaaS? (Platform as a Service)
Definition
PaaS provides application development and deployment platforms, allowing developers to focus on code without managing underlying infrastructure (such as OS, runtime, servers).
Azure and AWS Examples
| Cloud Platform | Service Name | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Azure | Azure App Service | Auto-scaling, built-in CI/CD, multi-language support |
| AWS | AWS Elastic Beanstalk | Auto-deployment, capacity provisioning, load balancing |
Use Cases
- Web Application Deployment: Quickly deploy websites and Web APIs
- Mobile App Backend: Provide backend services for mobile apps
- Microservices Architecture: Deploy independent small services
- Auto-Scaling Needs: Automatically adjust resources based on traffic
Practical Steps (Azure App Service)
- Create App Service
- In Azure Portal, select “Create a Web App”
- Choose runtime stack (.NET, Java, Node.js, Python, PHP)
- Deploy Application
- Auto-deploy via Git, GitHub Actions, Azure DevOps
- Or use FTP, ZIP deployment for manual upload
- Configure Settings
- Set application settings (environment variables)
- Configure auto-scaling rules
- Set custom domain and SSL certificate
Cost Considerations
- Billed by App Service Plan (different performance tiers)
- Includes auto-scaling, monitoring, backup features
- No server management, reducing operational costs
PaaS vs IaaS Comparison
| Item | IaaS | PaaS |
|---|---|---|
| Management Responsibility | Manage OS, middleware | Only manage application and data |
| Deployment Speed | Slower (need to setup environment) | Fast (environment ready) |
| Flexibility | Highly flexible | Limited by platform features |
| Use Cases | Need full control | Rapid development and deployment |
3. What Is SaaS? (Software as a Service)
Definition
SaaS provides complete software application services. Users access them directly through browsers or applications without installing, maintaining, or managing any infrastructure.
Azure and AWS Examples
| Cloud Platform | Service Name | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Microsoft | Microsoft 365 | Office suite, Email, collaboration tools |
| AWS | Amazon WorkSpaces | Virtual desktop without managing physical machines |
Use Cases
- Office Software: Word processing, spreadsheets, presentations (Microsoft 365, Google Workspace)
- Collaboration Platforms: Team communication, project management (Slack, Trello, Asana)
- Customer Relationship Management: CRM systems (Salesforce, Dynamics 365)
- Human Resource Management: HR payroll systems (Workday, BambooHR)
Features
- No Installation Required: Use directly through browser
- Automatic Updates: Service provider handles updates and maintenance
- Subscription Billing: Usually billed monthly or annually
- Multi-Tenant Architecture: Multiple customers share infrastructure
Cost Considerations
- Billed by user count (per user/per month)
- No infrastructure costs
- Includes all updates and maintenance
Complete IaaS, PaaS, and SaaS Comparison
| Service Model | Azure Example | AWS Example | Management Responsibility | Use Cases |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IaaS | Azure Virtual Machines | Amazon EC2 | User manages OS and above | Full control, legacy migration |
| PaaS | Azure App Service | AWS Elastic Beanstalk | User manages app and data | Rapid development, Web/API |
| SaaS | Microsoft 365 | Amazon WorkSpaces | User only uses software | Office software, collaboration |
Decision Tree for Selection
How to Choose the Right Service Model?
- Need full infrastructure control?
- Yes → Choose IaaS
- No → Continue
- Need to develop custom applications?
- Yes → Choose PaaS
- No → Continue
- Can use ready-made software?
- Yes → Choose SaaS
Common Issues and Solutions
Issue 1: How to Migrate from IaaS to PaaS?
Solutions:
- Assess application compatibility (does it support PaaS environment)
- Use Azure App Service Migration Assistant evaluation tool
- Gradual migration: migrate stateless services first, then handle databases
- Use containerization (Docker) as intermediate step
Issue 2: What Are the Limitations of PaaS?
Solutions:
- Limitations: Cannot install custom system software, fixed runtime environment
- Approach: Evaluate if custom features are truly needed, or consider container services (Azure Container Instances, AWS Fargate) as compromise
Issue 3: How to Optimize Costs?
Solutions:
- IaaS: Use Reserved Instances to reduce costs by 40-60%
- PaaS: Choose appropriate App Service Plan, utilize auto-scaling
- SaaS: Annual subscriptions typically 15-20% cheaper than monthly
Conclusion
Understanding the differences between IaaS, PaaS, and SaaS helps you:
- Make correct technical decisions: Choose the right service model based on requirements
- Optimize cost structure: Avoid over-provisioning or under-provisioning
- Improve development efficiency: Choose appropriate abstraction level
- Reduce operational burden: Transfer management responsibility to cloud service providers
Recommendations:
- For new projects, prioritize PaaS to accelerate time-to-market
- For legacy application migration, start with IaaS then gradually modernize
- For office and collaboration needs, directly choose SaaS
- Mix different models to meet different requirements
Related Articles
- Azure / AWS 中的 IaaS、PaaS 與 SaaS 概念與應用範例
- AWS Outage Deep Dive: Multi-Cloud Disaster Recovery Strategies for Architects
- AWS, Azure, and GCP Cloud Certifications Complete Comparison Guide (2025 Latest)
- Azure SQL Post-Migration Performance Optimization: Query Statistics, Top SQL Analysis, and Index Tuning Guide
- Azure DMZ Implementation Guide: Complete Handbook for Security Professionals